Abstract
Selecting appropriate preclinical models is fundamental for translational oncology, yet a large-scale, multi-omic quantitative comparison of their similarity to primary human tumors is lacking. To address this, we integrated transcriptomic, proteomic, and genomic profiles from over 10,000 primary tumors from The Cancer Genome Atlas (TCGA) and the Clinical Proteomic Tumor Analysis Consortium (CPTAC), alongside 4,000 preclinical models. Using a robust computational framework, we revealed a clear hierarchy of transcriptomic and proteomic similarity to patient tumors: patient-derived xenografts (PDXs) > patient-derived organoids (PDOs) = PDX-derived organoids (PDXOs) > cell lines. We also quantified high molecular conservation (Pearson correlation coefficient = 0.96) across paired in vitro to in vivo platform (organoids to PDX) transitions. Furthermore, genomic analysis demonstrated that whole-exome sequencing (WES) outperforms RNA sequencing (RNA-Seq) in detecting DNA variants, and it identified a clonal complexity hierarchy (cell lines > PDXOs > PDXs > PDOs) reflecting the impact of passaging history on intra-tumor heterogeneity. Ultimately, this study delivers a comprehensive quantitative benchmark, establishing a population-level hierarchy of molecular similarity between preclinical models and primary tumors, and providing a data-driven reference for model selection. These findings offer a data-driven framework for selecting models that balance biological representativeness with experimental practicality.
Authors
Zixuan Xie, Jia Xue, Binchen Mao, Hengyuan Liu, Wubin Qian, Jingjing Wang, Xiaobo Chen, Sheng Guo
This file is in Adobe Acrobat (PDF) format. If you have not installed and configured the Adobe Acrobat Reader on your system.
Having trouble reading a PDF?
PDFs are designed to be printed out and read, but if you prefer to read them online, you may find it easier if you increase the view size to 125%.
Having trouble saving a PDF?
Many versions of the free Acrobat Reader do not allow Save. You must instead save the PDF from the JCI Online page you downloaded it from. PC users: Right-click on the Download link and choose the option that says something like "Save Link As...". Mac users should hold the mouse button down on the link to get these same options.
Having trouble printing a PDF?
- Try printing one page at a time or to a newer printer.
- Try saving the file to disk before printing rather than opening it "on the fly." This requires that you configure your browser to "Save" rather than "Launch Application" for the file type "application/pdf", and can usually be done in the "Helper Applications" options.
- Make sure you are using the latest version of Adobe's Acrobat Reader.
