The mitochondrial uniporter is a selective Ca²⁺ channel regulated by MICU1, an EF hand‐containing protein in the organelle's intermembrane space. MICU1 physically associates with and is co‐expressed with a paralog, MICU2. To clarify the function of MICU1 and its relationship to MICU2, we used gene knockout (KO) technology. We report that HEK‐293T cells lacking MICU1 or MICU2 lose a normal threshold for Ca²⁺ intake, extending the known gating function of MICU1 to MICU2. Expression of MICU1 or MICU2 mutants lacking functional Ca²⁺‐binding sites leads to a striking loss of Ca²⁺ uptake, suggesting that MICU1/2 disinhibit the channel in response to a threshold rise in [Ca²⁺]. MICU2's activity and physical association with the pore require the presence of MICU1, though the converse is not true. We conclude that MICU1 and MICU2 are nonredundant and together set the [Ca²⁺] threshold for uniporter activity.